Common Roof and Shared Courtyard Guide — Rights and Laws
Leave your details — we’ll get back to you
We’ll respond within 24 hours
What Are a Common Roof and Shared Courtyard?
A common roof and shared courtyard are built parts of a building that do not belong to individual residents, but rather to all of them together. The common roof typically includes the top of the building and may contain infrastructure, ventilation systems, shared air conditioning, elevators, stairwells, and antennas. The shared courtyard, on the other hand, is the common outdoor area — access routes, parking lot, garden, shared porch, or any space that is shared by all building residents.
In accordance with the Condominium Law (1961), every unit in a condominium building is entitled to use common areas such as the roof and courtyard — but subject to the rights of other residents and building regulations. This means you have a right of use, but also obligations and responsibilities.
The Difference Between Ownership and Right of Use
An important point to understand: you do not own the common roof or courtyard. You are a unit owner, and through this ownership you have a right of use and co-ownership of the common areas. This right is registered in the land registry (Tabu), and you hold it together with other residents in the building. This means you cannot sell, lease, or grant others the use of the roof or courtyard separately from your own unit.
Your Rights to Use the Common Roof and Shared Courtyard
As a unit owner in a condominium building, you have a system of rights established by the Condominium Law and the land registry documentation of your unit. These rights include the right to use the common areas for residential purposes and their maintenance, without infringing on the rights of other residents.
Right to Use the Shared Courtyard
In a shared courtyard, you have the right to use the space for residential purposes and daily activities — for access to your unit, children's play (if there is a designated area), bicycle storage, or storage. However, you must refrain from activities that are disturbing or affect other residents, such as placing heavy objects, using the courtyard for commercial purposes, or altering the appearance of the courtyard.
Right to Use the Common Roof
On a common roof, your right is typically more limited. You are generally not permitted to use the roof for residential purposes or for purposes other than maintenance and infrastructure. However, in some buildings or under specific community agreements, there may be limited use rights — for example, hanging laundry, maintaining personal unit systems (such as air conditioning or solar water heater), or even adding a balcony or sukkah under certain conditions. This depends on the building's by-laws and the land registry registration.
Right to Participate in Decisions
As a unit owner in a condominium building, you have the right to participate in decisions concerning the maintenance, repair, and management of the common roof and courtyard. These decisions are typically made through a vote of residents at an annual assembly or special meeting, and this is an important part of your rights as a unit owner.
Key Legal Issues Regarding Common Roof and Shared Courtyard
Maintenance and Payment Obligations
As a unit owner, you must contribute to the maintenance costs of the common roof and courtyard. These costs include cleaning, repairs, insurance, lighting, and management. Your share is determined according to your ownership percentage in the common areas (often based on the unit's area or number of units).
Alterations and Construction Rights on the Roof
If you want to add something to the roof — such as a balcony, solar water heater, solar system, or external air conditioning unit — you need the approval of the majority of residents and often also authorization from the condominium committee. Construction without permission may lead to civil litigation and an order for removal.
Disputes Between Residents
Disputes over the use of the roof or courtyard — such as noise, harassment, object placement, or illegal parking — may lead to lawsuits between residents. The first solution is typically discussion in the condominium committee, and if that fails — court proceedings.
Inheritance and Sale Rights
When you sell your unit, your rights in the common roof and courtyard are transferred to the new buyer. This is part of your land registry documentation. It is important to ensure that the buyer is aware of the rights and obligations associated with the common areas.
Urban Renewal and Roof Renovation
In urban renewal projects (Tama 38) and urban regeneration, there are often significant changes to the common roof and courtyard. It is important to understand your rights in this process and your compensation if your use of the common areas is affected.
Insurance and Liability
The condominium building must be insured. If there is damage to the roof or courtyard — such as a leak, fallen object, or accident — it is important to know who is responsible and which insurance covers the damage.
Duties and Responsibilities of Residents in a Multi-Unit Building
While you have rights to use the shared roof and courtyard, you also have important duties that you must comply with. Violation of these duties may lead to disputes with other residents, the building committee, or even legal claims.
Duty to Pay Common Expenses
Residents must contribute to the maintenance, management, and insurance costs of the shared roof and courtyard. These costs are typically determined by an annual decision of residents or a special resolution. If you do not pay your share — or if you delay payment — other residents or the building committee may file a claim against you in court.
Duty of Non-Harassment and Respect for Other Residents' Rights
You must use the shared roof and courtyard in a manner that does not adversely affect the rights of other residents. This means: no excessive noise, no harassment, no placement of objects that block space or create danger, and no use for purposes incompatible with residential living.
Duty to Maintain Appearance and Integrity
You may not alter, damage, or destroy shared components. If you need to make a change — such as installing a solar water heater on the roof — you must first obtain approval from the other residents and the building committee. Unauthorized alterations will result in an obligation to remove them and also to pay for any damages caused.
Duty to Comply with Building Regulations
Every multi-unit building has regulations (bylaws) that define the rules for using shared areas. You must comply with these rules. If you violate the regulations — for example, by placing objects in the courtyard or using the roof for an unauthorized purpose — you may be sued.
Common Disputes Over Shared Roof and Courtyard — Scenarios and Legal Risks
Disputes concerning shared roofs and courtyards are among the most common issues in multi-unit housing cases. Below are several typical scenarios that may lead to legal disputes:
Scenario 1: Placement of Objects in Shared Courtyard
A resident decides to place bicycles, planters, or additional trash bins in the shared courtyard without permission from the other residents. Another resident complains that the objects block the space and create a problem. This may lead to one resident filing for removal of the objects and payment of damages for nuisance.
Scenario 2: Construction on Roof Without Permission
A resident on the top floor decides to add a balcony or sukkah on the shared roof without approval from the residents or building committee. Another resident complains that the construction impairs the view, lighting, or shared space. The court will typically order the removal of the construction and also award damages.
Scenario 3: Non-Payment of Common Expenses
A resident refuses or delays payment of their share of maintenance costs for the shared roof and courtyard. The other residents or building committee file a lawsuit in court. The court will typically order payment of the debt, interest, and legal costs.
Scenario 4: Damage to Shared Roof
A leak in the shared roof affects one or more residents. The question is who is responsible — the resident who caused the damage, the multi-unit building, or insurance? This requires an examination of the circumstances, the building's insurance, and the resident's mortgage.
Scenario 5: Noise and Nuisance from Use of Roof or Courtyard
A resident uses the roof or courtyard in a manner that creates excessive noise — for example, hosting parties, installing a noisy external air conditioning unit, or using the roof for commercial purposes. Another resident complains of nuisance. This may lead to a court claim for nuisance and a demand to cease the activity.
Scenario 6: Parking in Shared Courtyard
A resident parks their vehicle in a shared parking space not assigned to them, or parks in a way that blocks access to other residents. This may lead to a nuisance claim or a request to relocate the vehicle.
Legal Procedure in Disputes Over Shared Roof and Courtyard
When there is a dispute concerning a shared roof or courtyard, there is a recommended procedure for resolution. Generally, the first step is to attempt settlement through discussion with the building committee. If this does not succeed, the next step is court proceedings.
Step 1: Discussion at the Building Committee
If you have a dispute with another resident or with the building committee regarding the use of the roof or courtyard, the first step is usually to file a complaint or request a hearing before the committee. The building committee is entitled to hear both parties and attempt to reach a settlement. If the committee makes a decision, it must be based on the building regulations and the Condominium Law.
Step 2: Application to Court
If you do not reach a settlement at the committee, or if you are dissatisfied with the committee's decision, you may file a lawsuit in court. Generally, disputes concerning shared roofs and courtyards are filed in the Small Claims Court (if the amount is less than 75,000 NIS) or in the District Court (if the amount is larger).
Step 3: Court Proceedings
In court, both parties will present evidence — documents, testimony, and legal arguments. The court will examine the land registry document, the building regulations, the Condominium Law, and render a decision. This decision may include: a ruling regarding rights and obligations, an order for demolition or repair, and an order for payment of damages or legal fees.
Urban Renewal (TAMA 38) and Shared Roof and Courtyard
In urban renewal projects, there are often significant changes to the shared roof and courtyard of the building. In TAMA 38 projects (urban renewal with building replacement), the old building is demolished and a new building is constructed. During this process, the roof and shared courtyard of the new building may be quite different from the old building — larger, smaller, or a completely different shape.
Your Rights in the Renewal Process
As a resident in a building undergoing renewal, you have important rights: (1) the right to be informed of the new plans and to participate in decisions; (2) the right to compensation if your use of the shared roof or courtyard is negatively affected; (3) the right to participate in the allocation of payments and rights in the new building. It is important to be involved in the process and to consult with an attorney if you believe your rights are being violated.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shared Roof and Courtyard
When Should You Consult with a Lawyer?
Disputes over the roof and common courtyard can be complex and require a deep understanding of the Strata Titles Law, land registry documents, and real estate law in general. If you are dealing with any of the following scenarios, you should consult with a lawyer experienced in real estate law:
- Dispute with another resident over use of the roof or common courtyard
- Request to add something to the roof (balcony, water heater, air conditioning unit) — to understand your rights and the procedure
- Damage to the roof or common courtyard that affects your apartment
- Lawsuit from the building committee or from another resident regarding shared costs or use of common areas
- Maintenance issues with the roof or courtyard that the committee neglects
- Urban renewal project that may affect your rights in the roof or common courtyard
- Sale of your apartment and you want to understand the legal implications of your rights in the common areas
A lawyer experienced in real estate law can help you understand your rights, guide you through the process, and represent you in court if necessary.
Need Legal Advice on Roof and Common Courtyard?
Our lawyers have over 18 years of experience in real estate law and multi-unit building cases. We can help you understand your rights, manage disputes, and represent you in court.
Leave your details — we’ll get back to you
We’ll respond within 24 hours